# Brazil's competition authority keeps a daily fine on WhatsApp over chatbot access

> CADE's tribunal unanimously upheld the finding that Meta and WhatsApp did not comply with an order to keep AI chatbots working on WhatsApp Business. For Brazilian numbers, the fine runs until they do.

Source: https://conversationalaidesign.com/news/cade-whatsapp-chatbot-access-fine.html. Author: Nelson Abacherli Kawakami. Published November 17, 2026. Verified.

## What happened

Brazil's competition authority, CADE, had ordered a preventive measure so that AI chatbots could keep using WhatsApp Business. It then found that Meta changed the terms to allow charges for chatbot messages while that measure was in force. Its administrative tribunal **unanimously upheld** the notice of violation against WhatsApp LLC and Facebook Serviços Online do Brasil. The rapporteur concluded that the companies stay subject to a **daily fine of BRL 250,000** until they comply.

## What the tribunal said Meta must do

- Let AI chatbots operate on WhatsApp **without additional charges for access**, as when the measure was imposed.
- Adopt **concrete mechanisms** so excluded chatbots can resume as before the change of terms. Suspending the new terms alone was not enough.
- Stop classifying chatbot messages as **marketing messages** charged per message, which the tribunal found went against the measure.

The companies argued that the measure did not forbid charging for the WhatsApp Business API and that the fee is commercially reasonable. The tribunal did not accept that.

## What is not known

CADE's page does not give the date of the vote, the date of the original measure, deadlines or the next procedural steps. Other reports of Meta appealing or of the global policy applying in Brazil were not confirmed.

## What this changes in design

- If your support assistant runs on WhatsApp in Brazil, **keep a plan for the channel's cost and rules changing**: a fallback channel, and conversation costs in your business case ([resolution, ROI and pricing](../cheatsheets/resolution-roi-pricing.html)).
- Do not build a design that works only on one provider's terms. Keep the conversation logic apart from the channel.
- Check the current status before launch: this is a live dispute.

## How this was verified

On 17 November 2026 the CADE page itself was read. It is the regulator's own text, so the decision and the fine are verified. The page does not state every date, and the story may move on. This is a summary for designers, not legal advice.

## Sources
- CADE: Tribunal upholds fine against Meta and WhatsApp (published 29 Apr 2026, updated 26 Oct 2026): https://www.gov.br/cade/en/matters/news/cade-upholds-fine-against-meta-and-whatsapp
- TechCrunch: After Italy, WhatsApp excludes Brazil from rival chatbot ban (Jan 2026): https://techcrunch.com/2026/01/15/after-italy-whatsapp-excludes-brazil-from-rival-chatbot-ban
